5.2 Sustainable finance and investment

ESG ratings analysis

We show you how ESG rating agencies and indices score your company, why, and which disclosure and performance improvements would move your scores most. It is for investor relations and sustainability teams at listed and bond-issuing companies in Saudi Arabia and the GCC.

Talk to us about this

Why it matters

International investors often screen companies using third-party ESG ratings before they read anything you publish. As more Saudi companies attract foreign capital, issue bonds and sukuk, or join global indices, these scores shape how they are seen. Each agency uses its own method, weights and data sources, so the same company can score well with one and poorly with another, which confuses boards and frustrates teams.

Companies often react to ratings by answering every questionnaire in full and hoping scores rise. Many low scores come from missing public disclosure rather than poor performance, or from agencies using outdated or wrong data. Good ratings work starts by understanding each method, checks the data the agency holds on you, and ranks improvements by effort and effect. It also stays honest: the aim is better disclosure and performance, not gaming a score.

Illustrative example

What does disclosure do to an ESG rating?

Ratings score what they can see. This example holds a company's performance constant and changes only what it discloses.

Illustrative exampleDisclosure and your rating

Same company, same performance. Choose what it discloses and watch the rating.

34out of 100

Illustrative bandE2 of 6 issues disclosed

Disclosing everything would take it from 34 to 63, band C, with nothing changed on the ground. The biggest single gain is business ethics, worth 8 points.

Illustrative weights and scores. Where data is missing, many rating methods fall back on a cautious estimate, often near the bottom of the sector. Every agency uses its own method.

A real analysis starts with how your agencies score your sector.

Ask about yours

Environment

Carbon emissionsWeight 20%

15

Water stressWeight 15%

15

Social

Health and safetyWeight 15%

72

Labour practicesWeight 15%

15

Governance

Board and ownershipWeight 20%

66

Business ethicsWeight 15%

15

What this shows

Where data is missing, many rating methods fall back on a cautious estimate, often near the bottom of the sector. Missing disclosure can cost a company more than weak performance.

In a real engagement

We look at how each agency that covers you actually scores you and which data it holds, then rank the gains: what better disclosure would change, and what needs real improvement on the ground.

What you receive

  • A summary of the agencies and indices that matter to your investors.
  • A breakdown of how each agency scores you, by theme and indicator.
  • A check of the public data each agency uses, with errors identified.
  • A ranked list of disclosure and performance gains, by effort and expected effect.
  • Guidance on responding to agency questionnaires and data reviews.

How we work

  1. PrioritiseWe identify which ratings your investors and lenders actually use.
  2. DecodeWe analyse each methodology and your current score at indicator level.
  3. VerifyWe compare agency data with your public disclosures and flag errors to correct.
  4. RankWe rank improvements and link them to your reporting and strategy work.

Standards and frameworks

  • GRI Standards
  • SASB Standards
  • IFRS S1 and IFRS S2
  • TCFD recommendations
  • GHG Protocol Corporate Standard
  • Saudi Exchange ESG Disclosure Guidelines

Questions

Which ESG ratings matter most?

It depends on who holds or might hold your shares and bonds. Widely used providers include MSCI, S&P Global's Corporate Sustainability Assessment, Sustainalytics and CDP. We start from your investor base rather than a fixed list.

Why do different agencies give us such different scores?

They measure different things. Some rate exposure to and management of ESG risks, others rate disclosure quality or performance, and each weights topics differently. Divergence is normal and does not mean one score is wrong.

Can you improve our score quickly?

Correcting data errors and publishing information you already have can lift scores at the next review. Gains from real performance improvement take longer. We do not promise specific scores, because the agencies decide.

Do we have to respond to every questionnaire?

No. Prioritise the agencies that matter to your investors, and make sure your public disclosures are complete, since many agencies rely mainly on public information.