3.3 Reporting, data and assurance

Benchmarking and tracking

We compare your ESG performance and disclosure with a peer set you agree, help you set targets, and give you a tracker to measure progress each year. It is for sustainability teams and holding groups in Saudi Arabia and the GCC that need to know where they stand and whether they are moving.

Talk to us about this

Why it matters

Boards and investors increasingly ask two questions: how do we compare, and are we improving. In Saudi Arabia, many companies now have net zero or ESG commitments linked to Vision 2030 and the Saudi Green Initiative, and PIF portfolio companies face their own expectations from their shareholder. A target without a baseline cannot be tracked, and a baseline without peers gives no sense of whether the ambition is reasonable.

Benchmarks often fail because the peer set is chosen for convenience, mixes sectors and sizes, or compares numbers calculated on different boundaries. Targets get set as round numbers with no link to a pathway. Good benchmarking uses a defensible peer set, compares like with like, and records the source and method for every data point. Good tracking uses the same definitions every year and explains changes in method openly.

Illustrative example

How much does the peer group change the result?

A benchmark is only as useful as its comparison. This example puts one illustrative company against three different peer groups.

Illustrative examplePeer benchmark

Same company, same numbers. Change who it is compared with.

3of 5 measures
where it leads

Against Saudi sector peers, it leads on carbon intensity, workplace safety and board independence, and trails on none.

Choosing the peer group is the first decision in a benchmark, and the one that moves the result most. We agree it with you, then track the same group every year.

An illustrative mid-size Saudi industrial company against eight illustrative peers. Not real company data. Each line is scaled so that right is better.

A real benchmark uses your sector, your peers and your own disclosures.

Ask about yours
  • Carbon intensity Leading 3rd of 9
  • Water intensity In line 5th of 9
  • Workplace safety Leading 3rd of 9
  • Local talent In line 6th of 9
  • Board independence Leading 3rd of 9

What this shows

The same numbers look strong against local peers and weak against global leaders. Choosing the peer group is the first decision in a benchmark, and the one that moves the result most.

In a real engagement

We agree the peer set with you before any scoring, use your own disclosures and data, and track the same group every year, so a change in your position reflects a change in your performance, not in the comparison.

What you receive

  • A peer set agreed with you, with the reasons for each choice.
  • A baseline comparing your performance and disclosure with those peers.
  • Targets with a clear base year, boundary and method.
  • A tracker with fixed definitions that you update every year.
  • A short summary for your board on where you lead and where you lag.

How we work

  1. Choose peersWe agree a peer set by sector, size, region and the investors who compare you.
  2. BaselineWe collect public data on you and your peers and normalise it so it is comparable.
  3. Set targetsWe help you set targets grounded in the baseline and, for climate, in recognised methods.
  4. TrackWe build the tracker and show your team how to update and report it each year.

Standards and frameworks

  • GCC ESG Disclosure Metrics
  • Saudi Exchange ESG Disclosure Guidelines
  • GHG Protocol Corporate Standard
  • SBTi Corporate Net-Zero Standard
  • GRI Standards
  • SASB Standards

Questions

How many peers should we compare against?

Enough to give a fair picture, usually a mix of regional peers and a few international leaders in your sector. Too many peers blur the comparison; too few make it easy to dismiss. We agree the set with you before collecting data.

What if our peers do not publish the data?

Public disclosure in the region is uneven, so some gaps are normal. We record what is missing rather than estimate it, and use disclosure quality itself as one of the comparison points.

Should our climate targets be validated by SBTi?

Validation adds credibility, especially with international investors and customers, but it requires a full emissions inventory including relevant Scope 3. We can set targets in line with SBTi methods first and help you decide whether and when to submit.

How does this connect to our ESG strategy?

The baseline and peer comparison are inputs to strategy and target setting. The tracker then shows whether the strategy is working, and feeds your annual report.